Being deep within a story you're writing, a piece you're painting or a comic you're drawing is why we do it. That moment of being lost inside the thing, fully engaged and almost a participant in the world you're making for me at least, is the magic I keep coming back for. It's being Dorothy from the Wizard of Oz, wandering the Yellow-Brick Road discovering in real time what's around the corner, and being so immersed within the journey as to be surprised by it as the reader or viewer might. It's this initial basic experience that I think inspires all artists to keep making work, and to start making it in the first place. But it's not how good work is made- at least not on its own.
The Wizard- the master behind the curtain manipulating the world through which Dorothy travels- is the other side of the coin. The God in the machine, the architect of the matrix that has through training, research and experience has learned the ins and outs of how the mechanics of the medium work and can be applied toward the work you are attempting to create.While it is from Dorothy we find our inspiration to make work, it is through the Wizard that the work gets made well. One can achieve a completed tale without both, but it seldom ever works as a final piece, if ever. You need both, and both in a deep and fully engaged way that also set up straps for losing yourself inside of each to the cost of the story you are attempting to craft. Below are further definitions and advice that may help you to navigate both shoals successfully without crashing to hard against them. Fair warning- this is an entirely personal and subjective thing and as such, the specifics are unique to each creative person. So find your own way, but take heed from us old farts as we have gone through this vale already and can point to some common sign posts along the way. So set the controls for the heart of the sun and let's do this:
As the creator, you too should never lose this aspect of making the story because it is from Dorothy that we beta test whether or not what the thing we're making works. We need to be able to surrender ourselves to her aspect so we can, when reading it, or being inspired to create it, we can check anc make sure the seals are holding and the piece is functioning. It is the gut that leads this aspect and the emotional thrill and soul that feeds it. It is from this place we are inspired to work and inspired by the work of others, and is arguably the most essential aspect to any art form whether you are a maker or viewer. Hers is a gossamer thing easily blown away by being pulled out of the story for any number of reasons- a bad soundtrack to a movie, (sorry Ladyhawk, but yours is the best example of how a bad score can kill a good movie), breaking the fourth wall of a film or play, or betraying in some basic way the illusion of truth you are agreeing to honor by making the work. It doesn't mean you have to create a naturalized world to create the circumstance for a Dorothy the way say, Andrew Wyeth might. A Basquiat piece can do the same thing. All you must do to keep her whole and on course is to stick to the basic laws of physics inherent throughout the work, story or piece. Consistency is Dorothy's best friend- to drag the analogy out too far, this is your Toto: Barking you back on course, but not as an outside guide, but as a companion throughout the story, right there alongside you all the way through. Dorothy is why you make art, but she's not how you make it well. For that you need to learn to be The Wizard.
BEING THE WIZARD
But there's a danger to The Wizarding ways too- it can kill your inner Dorothy. Or rather, it can make her forgotten and distant. It can and wants to turn into a technocrat. A watchmaker rather than a storyteller. And let's face it, all good art, whatever the forum or medium is about storytelling. You can function and even excel at your tale without having Dorothy at your side, but the glass ceiling inherent in this one sided approach will prevent you from every reaching greatness with it. The strictures and rules and DNA encoding required of the Wizard inherently divorce her from the proceedings. God cannot build the world while in the world. He can visit later and even lose himself to it, but the act of creating the world requires his absence from its moment to moment linear events. The Wizard is basically and truly academic. Its where a cogent reviewer operates from, and while it's important to learn those tricks and mechanical realities of your medium, it is just as important to unlearn them when you need to. What school or any class gives at its best ebb, is the tricks and ways of being the best Wizard you can be. The real and final trick is not losing Dorothy entirely while doing so, and knowing when to utilize one or the other, and why.
RIDING BOTH HORSES
So. Now you have both ends of the creative race understood and covered. There's variations on this here and there obviously, and again, it is ultimately a landscape subjective and unique to your own sensibilities. But the best creative, the artist at the zenith of his or her power is the one that knows how to be both at once, or alone when needed. You need to learn when to surrender yourself to Dorothy so that you can check the workings of your world, but you also have to know when to turn her off, rise above the map and fix the things that aren't working, and learn from those aspects that are.
I love me some hour-long dramas, but when I learned about how they work and the mechanicals of how they are created, the three act structure of a story, or the use of time and jeopardy, the hour-long drama became hard to engage with fully. And frankly hellish on anyone sitting next to me while watching. I could almost predict every turn, each resolution of jeopardy or even by seeing where we were in time during that hour, whether the crisis was to be permanent or resolved by the end of the show. I couldn't unlearn what I had learned and it prevented me from being able to surrender to the story being told by virtue of an over awareness of its coding. These last few years that has happily begun to ebb and I can now surrender my observant mind on a whim, so that even if I jump out of the book or episode, I can leap back in. Largely the guide and draw for this is character. We as humans are vain creatures and need to see ourselves in the stories we read. We need someone to root for. To reference another show, we need a Fleishman to act as our avatar through the Northern Exposure town of Cicely, Alaska. We need to have a Agent Dale Cooper drive into Twin Peaks as we might. It is the hook upon which we hang our narrative hats and do not under any circumstances think your tale can work without one.
The reason I can now divest myself of my Wizard mind while watching an hour long, or reading a comic or novel now, is I think for me, because Dorothy will not be put into a corner for long. She has risen back up so that I can witness the tale again as it is intended to be witnessed. Yes, sometimes I enjoy a show, film or book because I adore dissecting how it's made or expressed, but I also need to lose myself to the sweep of the tale being told, otherwise it is an empty exercise. This comes from being able to reconcile the roles and abilities of both Dorothy and The Wizard. Not doing this dooms you to the see saw of back and forth that creates clunky incohate work
Ignore the fear of losing Dorothy as you learn the ways of The Wizard. Usually we do end up dancing with them that brung ya, and returning to the core of why we met with and engaged with the art-form we are learning to execute professionally. It is the source from which we cam and is and should be ever present. We can phone in a job using the Wizard, but one can never dismissively phone in Dorothy. SO even as you climb through academia, and take on the ideas and points of view of your professors, teachers and guides, don't forget the need to unlearn it all so that when you need the knowledge, it'sa there waiting for you like tools in a well kept carpenter's studio. But likewise never forget the value of that learning. Someone like Chris Ware dosen't draw simplified cartoonish characters because he doesn't know how to draw anything else- quite the opposite. Chris can draw in a near Rembrandt classical style to beat the band. He chooses to make comics in the way he does because he understands how they are best effective as a means through which he can tell his story. That's the part of him that's being a good Wizard. The heart and pain and biographical reveal of the characters and events of the story that make these constructed cartoons feel so real and true, that's Chris being the best Dorothy. You have to learn how to fly without forgetting how to walk, and know the difference between the two when the need arises.
Learn to be critical of your work without succumbing to being a critic. Be creative and creatively interrogative. You have to plan and coordinate but remain open to being surprised and inspired by your work so you are motivated towards doing it again. You have to be in the balloon soaring upward and on the ground with the tether to reel the balloon back in. It's a schizoidal thing to do, I know, but it's essential to making good work, and then more importantly, doing it again.